Keeping with the Alderaan theme, I thought you guys would find this funny. I made it, it's now in sticker form on the back of my Camaro.

Naboo has open spaces just as well as tight streets. You can see the proof in EP 1-3

Theres only 1 or 2 shots of Alderaan in ep 3 How are you coming up with this?

Anyway, im done discussing 'lore' .

About tarkin he would not have mentioned it, because why would he be thinking about 20 years ago at the birth of the empire, he was more concerned with the way vader disapproved of a lot of what he was doing and how he hired people that kept disobeying orders(at least in vaders eyes, vader just needed a reason to kill his own men)

Mentioning Tatooine as a potential battleground is totally different, it's a pretty lawless (so you're not going to have to much trouble packing weapons as it the norm in a harsh place like that) world, there is a limited Imperial presense on this world. but it's also on the fringe, with Mos Eisley being a hotbed of crime, and a hub of illegal traffiking, so there's all sorts of dodgy stuff going on. Anything can happen out in the desert, so basically it's a location ripe for a little scrap between the Rebs and Imps.

FSDev| Bandu wrote:

Safe-Keeper wrote:

I dislike the idea pretty strongly as it's pretty clear to me there never was a battle at Alderaan. It's a peaceful, neutral planet, not to mention that they have no weapons so it'd have to be a fist-fight map. Heh, that could be an idea - First Strike Karate Mini-Mod .

Never a battle according to who?

There was never a battle on Tatooine but you see countless games using it as a stage. Even so, other games arnt lore. They make stuff up to fill the lack of battles seen or mentioned in the movies. Some people even see these made up battles from computer games as lore. Whats the difference between us and ,say, Pandemic?

As long as we dont contradict the storyline of SW then theres no problem.

Remember , Alderaan was at the centre of the birth of the Rebel Alliance. I may be mistaken but i believe they had silver weapons in ROTS.

It's clearly mentioned in Ep IV Alderaan was a pacifist world without weapons according to Leia, if there had been an armed conflict surely Tarkin would have mentioned that.

Should we get rid of Mos Espa then?

Safe-Keeper wrote:

I dislike the idea pretty strongly as it's pretty clear to me there never was a battle at Alderaan. It's a peaceful, neutral planet, not to mention that they have no weapons so it'd have to be a fist-fight map. Heh, that could be an idea - First Strike Karate Mini-Mod .

Never a battle according to who?

There was never a battle on Tatooine but you see countless games using it as a stage. Even so, other games arnt lore. They make stuff up to fill the lack of battles seen or mentioned in the movies. Some people even see these made up battles from computer games as lore. Whats the difference between us and ,say, Pandemic?

As long as we dont contradict the storyline of SW then theres no problem.

Remember , Alderaan was at the centre of the birth of the Rebel Alliance. I may be mistaken but i believe they had silver weapons in ROTS.

It's clearly mentioned in Ep IV Alderaan was a pacifist world without weapons according to Leia, if there had been an armed conflict surely Tarkin would have mentioned that.