Good Serversettings, Serverrules and good Admins can make a server playable.
Bad Serversettings, Serverrules and bad Admins make a server unplayable.
During the Old BF 2142 Times i played mainly on "Squadplay all the Way" from the IPD Clan (they came from Castle Wolfenstein:ET Scene and switch to BF2142 until QuakeWars).
"Squadplay all the Way" has had very good rules, Admins and Settings.
First Rule: Join a Squad. Admins kicked players who don't join a Squad.
Tactical Gamer has the same rule and uses a script for it:
http://bf2.fun-o-matic.org/index.php/Sc … adlessKick
A very good Setting was also a 120 sec Time limit bevor the Round starts to switch Teams and make Squads and give orders for the first attack.
Respawn Time was 15 secs (Standard), 0 secs are just stupid because when you get killed at respawn ther is no way to escape a spawncamper.
Autobalance is a good thing, using the team ration should allow to make 2 players more on one side possible.
Best moment on Squadplay was the Hunt for the Glitcher... 
During Play an admins stops the server and tells us on player was Glitching ... instant of simply kicking & banning him, both teams hunt him down until he lefts the server.
CYNIC, n. A blackguard whose faulty vision sees things as they are, not as they ought to be. Hence the custom among the Scythians of plucking out a cynic’s eyes to improve his vision
