That would be extremely annoying.
Excuse me, Ty, but have you ever played a flight sim? Blackout is in pretty much every single one, and I've never found it the least bit annoying.
I don't think it would, it's not doing anything but making it more annoying, the noobs can still press the up/down arrow key. I don't need to see the screen to get into a loopdy loop chase.
The reason they go into a loop chase is because they see the enemy fighter in their HUDs and think they can catch up with it if they fly in its direction. If the 3D map suddenly went away and darkness suddenly crept in on them from the edges of the screen... they'd stop rather fast.
But as Imperial says, it doesn't fit lore.
"One of the bitches actually gave birth while she was attacking, and her puppies joined in on the carnage."
--the awesomeness that is Boatmurdered.