Re: ATAT Titan

This is all very interesting stuff I never knew (or noticed). Good job THX smile

http://www.usfbf1942.com/forums/image.php?u=158&dateline=2006

Re: ATAT Titan

THX-1138 wrote:

What we see Veers destroy is the Main Power Generator, which in addition to supplying power to the base is also providing power to the Shield Generator, which we do not see but probably looks like that dish on Endor in Episode VI.

Actually the shield system on Hoth would have been a little different to that on Endor, after all that shield was being projected far out into space to encompass a facility the size of a small moon requiring the massive shield projector array used by the Empire there.

By comparison the shield system on Hoth was a localised shielded area which would have required a number of shield generator modules dotted across the frozen wasteland that made up the territory surrounding the Rebel Base. These would have been considerably smaller and probably camouflaged to make them harder to detect, their design would be akin to shield generator blisters on capital ships.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v600/TALON_TAW/TALONSIGNEWB-1.jpg
http://stats.fsmod.com/fssig.php?player=Talon-UK
http://stats.fsmod.com/sig/pilot.Talon-UK.png

Re: ATAT Titan

But the basic point I'm making is still valid:

What Veers destroys is the power supply to the shields, much faster than simply destroying the shields themselves. This then allows the Imps to begin landing troops and bombard the base from orbit.

http://i15.photobucket.com/albums/a378/killer_ewok/Benssigcopy.jpg

Re: ATAT Titan

So is there a shot in the movie where the gun was locked on to the round backbone-looking building and had the words "power generator" underneath it?  I ask because what they say and what things look like in star-wars has been proven to be wrong before.  I can easily point to the giant bubbles on top of the super star destroyer in RotJ.  We see those destroyed and the very next thing that is said is "the shield generator is down."  Lucas later admitted that those aren't shield generators, yet all of us thought they were.

Same with this here.  They blew up a target then the next message was "their shields are down, you may commence your landing."  Whether you want to argue the semantics of if it's a power generator or a shield generator, what everyone will believe is "if you shoot the funny round thing, the shield generator is dead."  As such I don't actually think it matters whether we call it a shield generator or a power generator, however my inclination is to call it a shield generator because that's what everyone associates it with.  And even if they are power generators, again, in RotJ Han destroyed the power generator for the Endor shield yet we still saw the shield generator explode.  It seems that in the movies, no matter what you destroy it's going to be a shield generator tongue

Interestingly Star Wars: Force Commander (one of my all-time favorite RTS games) had them as shield generators.  You could put them down and everything inside their "shield bubble" would gain shield ability.  As such even lucasarts has made this discretion/mistake before smile



I loved that game.  It was so great.  Multiplayer was also the best.  Except for when my kid brother discovered that you could rename troops to whatever you liked.  He would constantly rename single infantry men "Woodrow" and marched them up into the firing line to be "executed" to demonstrate what was going to happen to me tongue

Fear the Woodzilla

http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y283/Tortel/Woodrow-1.jpg

Re: ATAT Titan

LMAO Woody! he joy of sibling rivalry smile

http://www.fsmod.com/img/xero_ani.gif
Quote: Lafs1984 "He can't say no to an Ewok"
http://dickscab.com/fuckd/the_force.gif

20 (edited by FSDev| Pumbaa 2007-01-03 12:12:04)

Re: ATAT Titan

I don't feel I really have that much knowledge about the sw universe to jump in here, but I did a quick qookiepedia search and found all evidence pointing to THX-1138 theory. A search for shield generator http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Shield_generator and you see something similiar to what Han blows up on endor. Power generator didn't have any picture though. http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Power_generator

www.pee-baa.com - Online Portfolio of Peter Jansson!

Re: ATAT Titan

It seems that in the movies, no matter what you destroy it's going to be a shield generator tongue

Incorrect. No matter what you place a small amount of explosives on, something much bigger explodes.

--------------------------------------
If I should die, think only this of me:
That in some corner of a foreign field
There lies a plagiarist.