*sigh*
Yeah he's from Lord of the Rings, but he was a HOBBIT! Hobbits are small and pest-like!
Charlie just seems to choose roles that I don't like, therefore it makes me not like him.
Tough luck, Hobbit-boy.
Claire WAS a neutral in my book, then she came back with no memory of past-island events and more or less unharmed. She could have NEVER escaped from the others, especially while pregnant. They LET her go, but WHY? That means I'm watching her and waiting to see what happens.
Besides she has that british accent...only woman I know that can actually pull that off without it being mentally draining for me is Kate Beckinsale. (There's a Yum Yum Yum for ya, Foxy.) 

Bringing Jedi Closer To Extinction